Policy Instruments and Conflicts



Fiscal policy is the deliberate manipulation of government income and expenditure so as to achieve desired economic and social objectives.  The instruments of fiscal policy are taxation and government spending. Changes in the level, timing and composition of taxation and government spending can have a significant impact on people’s living.
Public spending is financed by various ways, 1) taxes levied by central government, 2) taxes levied by local authorities, 3) fees, 4) fines, 5) national insurance contribution, 6) borrowing 7) sales of assets, and 8) aids or grants.  Out of all the above, taxation provide the major contribution towards public spending.
Taxes are collected by government department.  Taxation will vary greatly between different countries,   how they differ, such as the distinction between direct taxes on income and indirect taxes on expenditure.
The direct taxes are taxes levied on income and capital. It is paid directly by the tax payer to the government.   The burden of direct taxes is borne by the person or company responsible for paying the taxes. 
Indirect taxes are taxes paid in the form of higher price indirectly through some others (Sellers, distributors or manufacturers) to the government. In this taxation   incidence is with the tax payer and its impact is passed on to another in the form of higher prices (such as sales tax).  
 There are various aims of government policy but there are possibilities that there may be possible conflicts between these aims.  The task of aiming to achieve one aim might conflict with the other aims, for example, the aim of reducing unemployment could conflict with the need to keep down the rate of inflation.  In order to achieve one goal government often sacrifice another. So policy makers are compelled to establish some scale of priorities (main concern). 

The major policy objectives are 1) full employment, 2) price stability, 3)   economic growth, 4) redistribution of income, and 5) balance of payments stability.  There are different forms of government policies. The best known are Fiscal policy and monetary policy.  Fiscal policy is the deliberate manipulation of government revenue (taxation) and government expenditure. Monetary policy is concerned with the changes in the supply and price of money.  There are other policies such as regional policies (which influence the location of industry) income policies (which influence incomes, especially wages). 

Failures in objectives occur when government intervention fails to improve economic efficiency (welfare).  It arises from a number of reasons.
  1)  It is difficult to achieve all the objectives simultaneously.  
2) Policy instruments will be making use of economic theory and forecasts which has conflicts of opinion between different economists.
3)  Governments receive advice from Treasury and from panel of independent economists. The strength of the advice depends on the accuracy of information gathered and the interpretation in the economic models used.
4) There will be delays involved in government policy, that is, time taken to recognize the problem, time taken to formulate policy measures, time taken to implement the policy and time taken people and firms to react to the policies. The economic circumstance will change from the time the problem is identified to the time of implementation. (E.g. change in seasons)
5) There are practical problems – national and international known as policy constraints.  It is difficult to change government expenditure, taxation and legislation quickly.
6) Economic advisers may recommend a rise in taxation, but if this is just before a general election, due to political influence a government may choose to ignore the advice.  [Governments tend to introduce harsh (cruel) measures just after an election and more popular ones near an election]  
7) The real world is a complex and constantly changing place, and therefore, it is very difficult to measure and control the economic components involved in the policy measures, [such as increasing mobility of money around the world makes more difficult to measure and control money supply]
8) Civil servants’ and politicians’ self-interest to pursue their own department or their own advancement (pay scale, promotion chances and status) may be influenced in policy decisions even if it is not in the country’s interest.   
                                                                        Back to Home Page Click here